Originality: 7/10 Plain Vista but with the taskbar stretched and on top
Neatness: 7/10 Desktop is neat, but taskbar is cluttered
Style: 4/10 Wallpaper looks very artificial (obviously) and I just don't really like Vista taskbars stretched or on top.


Here's mine.


EDIT: Woot this is the 800th post!

Overall: 9/10 Really like the colours and the way its organised

Originality: 7/10
Neatness: 9/10
Style: 10/10

I love it



edit: :3

Originality: 10 - Never seen that before
Neatness: 9 - A simple but functional dock
Style: 4 - The background is a little much to look at, but a good idea.



I know, weird resolution... 1336X1024 I think...
~Vincent

EDIT: It's 1336X768

Originality- 0, default unbuntu wallpaper and theme (And programs pinned to taskbar and etc).
Neatness- 7,
Style- It's default everything, so 0.

Mine hasn't changed since last time I posted.

Originality: 6
Neatness: 7 (too many stuff on the bar)
Style: 7 Cool background

Originality: 8/10 - Nice Start Menu icon... How did you get it?
Neatness - 9/10 - Quite Neat
Style - 10/10 I love the Max Clear theme and customized start menu icon!

~Vincent

Originality - 3/10, it's the default for Ubuntu.
Neatness - 9/10
Style - 5/10 It's the default theme and everything for Ubuntu.
Mine hasn't changed too much since I last posted, but I tidied up the Quick Launch bar.

Where do you get the clear theme for Vista (64-bit) anyway?
EDIT: Stupid Photobucket resizes large images like that.

Originality: 5/10
Neatness:7/10 Nice pic, looks a bit blurry
Style: 4/10 The overloaded, 2-layer taskbar

Been doing things to my desktop
The background is from Wikimedia commons, but I changed it a bit

Originality: 6/10 simple picture
Neatness: 8/10 no clutter, easy to navigate
Style: 7/10 very simple. i like.

Originality: 9/10
Neatness: 10/10 : Easy navigation
Style: 10/10 : Similar to mine; sexy.

Originality: 6/10 Default except for dock.
Neatness: 10/10 Very neat and organized.
Style: 10/10 I like it, not too overdone and stuff. I really like how the dock fits perfectly into the wallpaper

EDIT: +1 bonus style point for using WMP instead of iTunes. iTunes looks horribly out of place in Vista.


Here's another one of mine from a while back that I never posted here. I have since realized that docks are pretty but not practical, so I don't use them anymore.

Originality: 9/10
Neatness: 10/10
Style: 11/10 I really like how it all just meshes together...

My new desktop...I still haven't actually gotten rid of the HD icon though.

Originality: 7, looks just like every other OS X picture
Neatness: 7 No icons, but the dock is super full
Style: 6 too dark for my liking

Overall - 7

Originality - 5, seen the picture a few times before
Neatness - 8, looks like mine
Style - 7, liking the Win7 but not a fan of the transparency

Originality - 8/10 (shizzle, Megan Fox DOES have the same expression in every photo...that's creepy)
Neatness - 9/10 (I'm OC and I don't like the icons not lining up with the top of the screen )
Style - 3/10 (regular Vista/7 ftl)

new desktop and yes I did get rid of the HD icon now.

Originality - 7/10. I like the pic.
Neatness - 10/10. Not that much going on.
Style - 1/10. Same as above.

Originality - 9/10 - Nice Pic
Neatness - 9/10 - Things seem to be in their place
Style - 10/10 - Very interesting look overall, I like that theme

Mine

Originality 4
Neatness 2 WAY too many icons. Cluttered notification area.
Style 6 Picture is pretty cool, but looks stretched.

Originality 8 Pretty unique
Neatness 9
Style 3 personally I hate it

Magical-

Overall: 9.5/10 great desktop.
Originality: 9/10 I've never seen notepad on a desktop before.
Style: 8/10 <- That's what gives you the 10/10 neatness score.
Neatness: 10/10 no comment.

I see no picture above?

Here's mine.

Rating:
Originality: 6/10 Never seen anything like it..
Neatness: 8/10 The taskbar is very filled-up, but wouldn't make anyhting more there.
Style: 3/10 What can you say? Its all black..

Here's mine, not too different, but even more copy-cat-Apple when i have an itunes skin on Winamp called Tewnz..
And, anyone asks, its Rocketdock+iLimited by NLM Studios and Winamp with Tewnz skin.

(Seems like there must be a problem on ImageShack atm..)

Originality: 3/10 (It's a mac wannabe =P)
Style: 6/10
Neatness: 8/10 (Seems organized but i can't tell since the image is cut off.)

Its not cutoff, i use Stardock Fences to hide all icons, and i double-click to show them again. (Makes me see the backgrond better.)

Do you know if there is an iLimited theme for Windows Vista?

@Lidas:

Originality: 9/10, not seen a background similar to that, quite unique 'dock' too.
Style: 8/10, it's good. But it's not great...
Neatness: 7.5/10, no icons are neater icons, but you could at least make the effort

Total: 8.25/10

So i decided to bid farewell to Vista with one last wallpaper, that i found when i was searching through my camera's SD card:

Originality: 5/10, seems like a typical landscape background and icon layout.
Style: 5/10, I don't really see "style", except for the way you arranged your icons.
Neatness: 7/10, the amount of icons is a little too much for me, and your notifications area in your taskbar is pretty full.

Overall, 6/10. Nothing too special.

I edited my icons again so that they would match the current background (thank God for Photoshop and color mixers!). The taskbar and dock are on Auto-Hide, so all you see is the background unless you mouse over their respective areas.

I took that picture myself! My notifications are only has one thing on it that i don't need, and that's Vista trying to get my to download SP2, which is pointless since it'l be replaced by Windows 7 when i get the disks. I've never seen anybody else set out their icons in that way, and i make use of them all...

Can i ask for a second opinion?

Originality: 8/10 - nice dock icons
Style: 8/10 - dock icons match background.
Neatness: 10/10.

I hate when people give a 9/10 for a really neat background. What consists of a 10?

Anyways, if this doesn't get a 10 for style, you guys don't know how to rate. I'm serious.

Originality: 8/10 - Interesting
Style: 8/10 Looks pretty good
Neatness: 9/10 Quite neat...

Overall: 8.5/10

Mine:

~Vincent

Originality: 7/10, I think I might've seen that image before, but I can't remember where.
Style: 7/10 It looks pretty good, but I don't really like the stuff on the bottom of the screen.
Neatness: 8/10
I cleaned up my Quick Launch thing quite a bit since I last posted here.

Originality: 6/10
Style: 5/10 Basic, just kind of a basic somewhat-interesting bloated picture
Neatness: 8/10 Neat, but I don't like the thick taskbar

Experimenting with a blander style, which looks better with my full glass window theme. Taskbar is on top with auto-hide, dock is also auto-hide.

Originality: 10/10 ive never seen this image before and looks pretty nice
Style: 7/10 pretty nice, it bit bland as you said
Neatness: 8/10 your applebar? is a bit messy
id say a 8.5/10 pretty nice desktop though

its not vista its xp, as you can see i love star wars.

Originality - 8/10. Star Wars is cool.
Style - 7/10. Pretty basic XP/Vista look.
Neatness - 8/10 Not too bad.

Originality - 6/10. Seen a few like that...
Style - 8/10. Nice to look at, but it lacks that 'take your breath away' effect. Then again, it is a desktop wallpaper so whatever floats your boat.
Neatness - 7.5/10. You missed a spot... if there's nothing there to mess up anyway then you just haven't made the effort.

Total - 7/10

Originality - 7/10. - I love it
Style - 9/10. Very - nicely constructed.
Neatness - 8/10 - allows wallpaper to be more visible

Total - 8/10

Originality - 10/10: Never seen a desktop like that.
Style - 8/10 I like it, the only thing that gets me is the alien and the repeated background pattern. Other than that it's great.
Neatness - 10/10. Perfect.

Just put windows 7 on my netbook today, decided to make a custom theme and then hook it up with rocketdock.

Originality- 8/10
Style- 10/10, I like it.
Neatness- 10/10, no Icons

Originality 5/10 Just about average
Style- 8/10 Nice Background!
Neatness- 7/10 Not many icons but folders are cluttering

Originality: 5/10 Nothing to original; but still simple!
Style: 8/10 I like the background!
Neatness: 8/10 Pretty Neat

Mines extremely simple considering I mainly use the dock to load the applications I use.
I really like my MJ background, it's so crisp and awesome


~Darth

Originality: 8/10, a lot of MJ stuff going around these days, but I've never seen that one before. Very unique.
Style: 9/10, the purple galaxy and monotone MJ match the silver of the Mac OS perfectly!
Neatness: 10/10 Minimal Dock usage and no icons whatsoever on the desktop! Very nice!

Overall 9/10. Very good job.

I FINALLY HAVE WINDOWS 7!!#!!@@@!!!!@!11!!1!1! I changed my dock to better match my custom icons and taskbar. I've arranged the icons by category - music, games, office, etc. The background changes to a different Danboard background every 5 minutes, so that's just the current one. To see the others, just take a look at my previous posts in this thread. The taskbar and dock are on Auto-Hide, so all you see is the background unless you mouse over their respective areas.

I like the dock you use, what is it called?

9/10 for your desktop.



By the way my desktop is dual monitor, so here goes:

7/10 It's clean but plain. The background on the right is little too abstract to fit the theme the left one sets.

Absolutely love it. 9.5/10. Little too much icons for my liking, though.

7/10 Its very clean but a little bit plain if I was allowed to I would give you 10 because you have oblivion.

You gotta teach me on how to use Rainmeter Beret.

Jordo: 7/10 Dfault background picture... But +1 for the "Rate my Desktop" program!

Here's mine, getting Windows 7 this week!!!

Shortcuts are a little cluttered, but all in all i'd say about a 7/10 =]


Again, my desktop has two monitors, one is smaller than the other (Hence the Blackness in the print screen)

http://imagebeast.net/images/yehahtgc9ts3xk8s07t.png

Sorry I couldn't answer you before, it's called Leopard Elite. There are two colors - Smoke (Black) and Pearl (White). I didn't like the separators that came with it so I added my own.

About 6/10. Not really my style, and anyway, the picture to the right doesn't look very good.
Finally, a wallpaper that I should be keeping for a while.

Can you tell me where you got the wallpaper