Please make your reasons good; not something like, "It's c00l 4nd 1337" A good example would be, "I love how you blended everything together. I love your text, and great c4d choice!"






Theme: Famous Mathematician/Scientist/Philosopher/Someone-who-has-given-a-famous-speech.

Entrillity




Chrispperson




Symphony




Char-Lite




Dhru 7777777




- Umesh




Cat




A D A M




I haveanidea

Place 1 (3 pnts)Symphony
Reason: Awsome text and great blending, there is some funky colors far off to the right though

Place 2 (2 pnts)Umesh
Reason: Great use of vivid colors and text, looks a little blank on the top though

Place 3 (1 pnt)I haveanidea
Reason:Great effects & lighting, his back shoulder is cut off a bit though. Also, his forehead looks a bit choppy & the text is hard to read

In your opinion, were any of these flawless (optional)? No or I would need a new pair of boxers by now

Place 1 (3 pnts)Charlite
Reason: I really like the simplicity in this, and the text looks great in context with the image =) Nice

Place 2 (2 pnts)Umesh
Reason:Nice colors and smudging, some flaws, but still =)

Place 3 (1 pnt)Symphony
Reason:The text doesn't really work, but the rest is good.

In your opinion, were any of these flawless (optional)?Mine? Lol joking.

By the way, in the voting topic, you should include the theme so people know, because that can affect votes.

I did, but it apparently is obvious. Let me make it pop-out more.



------------------------------------------------------

Entrillity- 0


Chrispperson- 0


Symphony- 4


Char-Lite- 3


Dhru 7777777- 0


- Umesh- 4


Cat- 0


A D A M- 0


I haveanidea- 1

3 pts: Cat - I really love the simple background, nice lighting effects on the render too. The text saying 'Cat' is the only thing I don't really like.
2 pts: Umesh - I really like the overall flow of this one, the colors around Einstien are :3
1 pt: ihaveanidea - This one, like all this guy's sigs, is pretty dern nice. The c4d in the background is a little much, but overall not bad.

None of these really 'wow'd me, but there were some decent sigs.

Entrillity- 0


Chrispperson- 0


Symphony- 4


Char-Lite- 3


Dhru 7777777- 0


- Umesh- 6


Cat- 3


A D A M- 0


I haveanidea- 2


----------------------

1st Place (3pts): Symphony - Love The Way That The Background Fades But Yet There Is Still The Flag With The Bubble Effect. The Text Really Ties Into The Whole Piece. Very Nice!

2nd Place (2pts): Umesh - Einstein Being The Center Of The Piece Was A Very Good Idea, The Glowing Colors Around It Really Draws Attention To The Center Piece Like I Didn't Realize At First.

3rd Place (1pt): Cat - The Picture Of Martin Luther King Jr. Really Pops Out Against The Black And White US Flag, The Two Different Texts Makes This Piece Really Stands Out.

Place 1 (3 pnts)Symphony
Reason:It just looks spectacular...great transparencies

Place 2 (2 pnts)Adam
Reason: Looks pretty cool, i like the black in it

Place 3 (1 pnt)ihaveanidea
Reason:looks great looks powerful

Lmao, I'm going to die

At least I tried...
It was a first try

This contest isn't just about winning; and you've improved so much! Don't give up!

----------------------------

Entrillity- 0


Chrispperson- 0


Symphony- 10


Char-Lite- 3


Dhru 7777777- 0


- Umesh- 8


Cat- 4


A D A M- 2


I haveanidea- 3


-----------------------

+1, I remember my first SotW contest... I didn't get one point lol. I kept accpeting challenges and doing battles and later entered anouther SotW battle and actually started getting points. You can only improve, so each time you make a sig, you are doing good for yourself

I still don't get very many points, though I really didn't do anything special with this one

3 p.ts)Symphony-i like it, its nice....
2 pts) Cat- very nice...
1 pt) umesh: its nice and all, and its alright

i probably could not do anything like this, there all pretty good =)

I'll say that none of them are flawless...

Lol, your idea was still extreamely cunning though

I guess I'll close the voting now; any objections?

No, I think the standings are blatantly obvious

Wait no!

Hopefully this counts but anyways...

3 Points: Dhru, I really love the lighting in that tag but the only thing wrong is the pen tool like you told me before.

2 Points: Symphony, I really like the blending but the text looks out of place and there are some colors that are off-set on the right side.

1 Point: Umesh, I like the blending and smudging but the colors don't flow with the signature. I'm sure if it wasn't a black/white picture then it would have been fine or if the blending was the same colors.

It counts

-----------------

Entrillity- 0


Chrispperson- 0


Symphony- 12


Char-Lite- 3


Dhru 7777777- 3


- Umesh- 9


Cat- 4


A D A M- 2


I haveanidea- 3


-----------------------

Oops, forgot to vote. Again. Is it too late?

3 points - Symphony. Great lighting and colours. Nice text. Great sig.
2 points - Umesh. Awesome smudging and text.
1 points - Ent. Luvin' the dinosaur Any way, simple but great

Also, Ptolemy, looking back through the topic, I have 6 votes not 4
And also it's probably time to end it soon.. lol

Good luck everyone
Cat