SOTW 72 Voting

Rules:

- Select your top three; 1^st place gets 3 points, 2^nd gets 2, and 3_rd gets 1.
- You can NOT vote for yourself.
- Either use the voting form (below), or vote similarly.
- Can NOT vote twice.

Please make your reasons good; not something like, "It's c00l 4nd 1337" A good example would be, "I love how you blended everything together. I love your text, and great c4d choice!"







Theme: set character: Daxter from the game Jak and Daxter



Nirvan33b Dhru




Umesh





Ahmad




Let the voting begin.

You posted Dhru's twice.
3 pts for Ahmad, nice and soft colors.

You have to have a 2 pts and 1 pts.

3 points: Ahmad, very nice colors, nice soft colors as Youhei said.
2 points: Umesh, blending is a nice, but, it's pretty repeated.
1 point: Dhru, its very sharp and choppy at some points.

Place 1 (3 pnts) Ahmad
Reason: Nice depth, loved the background. The image just fit in to the signature.

Place 2 (2 pnts) Umesh
Reason: Not as... Interesting. It was very nice, and it was great how you blending the image just right into the background (actually more than Ahmad, but I still like Ahmad's better )

Place 3 (1 pnt) Nirvan33b Dhru
Reason: It was good... Just... I didn't like how 'grungey' it was, and how it was a little hard to see the render.

In your opinion, were any of these flawless (optional)? Sorry guys, nope

Damn. In the past you can just vote for one.

3- Umesh - nice blending, but it does take over the entire sig
2- Ahmad - lost 1 point from me because colors didnt go well
1- no one, i cant vote fur myself.

3 points for Ahmad. Pretty good, although the white is not a good form of lighting.

Nobody else deserves a vote.

Ahmad +3 points for being the lesser of the three evils. =/

Ahmad +3 points for being the lesser of the three evils. =/

Place 1 (3 pnts) Ahmad
Reason: It's not perfect, the soft lighting ruins it, but it's better than the other two.

Place 2 (2 pnts) Umesh
Reason: Good render, but it's too smudged.

Place 3 (1 pnt) Dhru
Reason: Good background, but the render looks messed up. It also doesn't set off the animal side of Daxter.

In your opinion, were any of these flawless (optional)? Nope, sorry.

Uh oh! You pressed the "add reply" button twice!

I'll tell the mods it was an accident

3 points - Ahmad. Good render, lighting and some pretty sweet effects.

So many people voted only 1 person and you say I'm wrong. What the heck?

The original rules were that you had to vote for 3 people. One having 3 points, 1 having 2 points, and 1 having 1 point. Guess it's changed since then.

It's been allowed since the orginal sotw (according to the numbers atleast), it just has to be justified. So many people are doing it this time, tho, because only one sig deserves the points. =/

Well that's cause everyone left who is good. Aside from a few people.

Yup. Left, quit, or just don't bother with sal's graphics area anymore.

there are 3 people in a sotw


this place is really dead

It's been this way for a while now.

It's depressing. =(

If you come back, all the dead spirits will rise from the dead.

3 pts - Ahmad - The text isnt the best i've seen, but i really like the render choice and the soft colors.
2 pts - Umesh - Not a bad render, but the effects and the colors aren't that good.
1 pts - Dhru - I don't like the render you used and how you blended it, but it's still a pretty decent signature anyway.

You know what? I think we know who the winners are. I'm just going to make a topic about the SOTW 72 Results.