vote ur top 3@@@@ voting ends sometime on the 20th, saturday

Ahmad


dabmasta


Swagga


Ptolemy


Kwinten


Doomsicle


-REAP-


Runez


Celtic


Shepherd


Dhru is Envoked


sanji


Chateau-L


A D A M


Fatalysm

Lotsa entries this week:

3pts : Fatalysm, although the balance is off I like the smokey effect

2pts : Sanji, not much wrong with it but lacks a bit of interest.

1pt : Shepard, although the light engulfing his head bothers me, it works better in B/w format than most of the others.

3: fatylsym-love it

2.dhru-nice effect

3.a d a m- i dont really know why, just like it.

I'm pretty sure Kwinten's isn't BW

O yes it is.

Lol people make time to make a sig, then have enough time to check the post and respond to queries but then cant be arsed to vote. This has always been SoTW's failing on this site, nobody bothers to vote even if they entered (Probably out of self interest but I cant comment)

O NO IT IS NOT

ORG

BW


owned, boy

dabmasta

Runez

Shepherd

3 points - Celtic - It seems like a general thing to say, but the use of light and dark with black and white looks fantastic. You have also used some rather nice effects that set the piece well.
2 points - Shepard - I think it is a little to busy for my own liking, mainly because of the lack of color. The white lighting is a little off putting but overall the signature is good. I'd add some more miniture details around the main focal.
1 point - Ahmad - Although it looks very (samey) to a lot of other signatures, i still think you have applied lighting pretty well. Once again, work on smaller details, and perhaps make them sharper !

3 points: Fatalysm (Awesome signature, good luck!)

2 points: Ahmad (I don't like the text, sorry.)

1 point: Ptolemy (Yoshi for the win!)

Yeah right. I used a lighter filter, boy.

celtic- best compo there
fatalysm- like it but the lines and text kinda throw it off
runez- good balance but lacks a general depth

Is that 100% grayscale like the rules say? NO, boy

But why am I worried? you won't win lol

fatalysm - love the smoke thing
sanji - idk i just like it
celtic- its really nice but it just looks a little off to me, i cant think of what tho

3pt-celtic-amazing flow and effects, good comp overall.

2pt-fatalysm- good flow and effects as well, but could have had more depth and clearer focal.

1pt-dabmasta-ilike the fx but the depth and contrast could be worked on.

3 pts - Celtic - Come on, it's Celtic. Nice fx but something's missing...
2 pts - sanji - it's a little plain but overall it's good. needs more detail on fx imo.
1 pt - runez- oversharpened, little busy bg but quite decent.

3 Points-Fatalysm. I love a lot of his work, and that is definitely one of the best pieces of his.
2 Points-Ptolemy. I like the render and the fighting look on its face. I also like the blending.
1 Point-Shepherd. I don't like the light effect at the top, but I definitely like the rest.

Yea, because they can't vote for themselves, and they don't want to give they're competitors votes. xD

I voted for other people, I don't see why other people don't vote. It's not like it's the end of the world if you lose. Besides, if you don't vote after entering does that mean people are arrogant enough to think that their's is the best?

CBA to count but it looks like around 1/3 of entrants voted, really classy especially those who posted in the topic and then didnt even vote. The sad thing is nothings changed for like 3 years, I remember a few years back I wanted a "you enter you vote" rule but people thought it a bit totalitarian.

runez- really love the placement of tha c4d.

sanji- i love how its so simple but still captures tha eye. [nd dat girl is alright too hehe.]

celtic- i really like this one and it was the only choice i had for 3rd place. i love how its so big, but i really dont feel any emptiness anywhere really. love it.

I know i havent voted, but I think that we should set up that rule that celtic mentioned, as it is only fair.

So i guess i will vote


3 pts- Celtic because of the neat effects

2pts- Fatalysm because right side is a bit negative

1 pt- Sheperd because it doesnt look that appealing to me

a 'you enter you vote' rule would be great.

Ahmad - 3 points - I like the lighting and the way the text fits the whole sig overall.

Runez - 2 points - I like the effects and text.

-Reap- - 1 point - I like reap's style of smudging, though theres a giant part of the sig that empty.