Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Sotw 76 Voting
Sal's RuneScape Forum > Everything... Not RuneScape > The Graphics Place > Digital Gallery > Competitions & Projects
One
Voting Rules:
  • You may vote for up to three entries.
  • You must make it clear which signature is your favorite, second favorite, and third favorite.
  • Points will be awarded for favorite signatures (3 pts), second favorite (2 pts), and third favorite (1 pt)
  • You must give reasons for your votes. This reason must be something to do with what the artist has done in the signature (eg: color, style, blending).

Rizzo:

Poke:

Dhru is Envoked:

Shepherd:

Ahmad:

dabmasta

Swagga

Dwarrior

-Arch

Celtic

Redmonke

-Trevor-

Mario

Ethiopia

Nadson

Kwinten

Runez
Dwarrior
Ethiopia 3 - I love the effects and the blending of the render with the background.
-Arch 2 - I like the background and the text.
Nadson 1 - Love the way the render blends with the back ground
Easl
Poke - 3 Love the colours and its very siimple and clean
Mario- 2 Again great colours, and good use of shadows
Kwiten - 1 Great landscape, looks fantastic
Runez
I am completely and utterly offended that you forgot to add in my entry. A host should be more cautious of such mistakes for it can change the very outcome of the contest.
http://runescape.salmoneus.net/forums/inde...t&p=3287732

Kidding, it's fine. I don't plan on winning anyways. I hope I didn't offend you. smile.gif
No, seriously don't add mine......I see so many good sigs there that I want to QQ.
Alann
Poke - 3 Points - I think his fits the theme of paradise the best.
Dabamasta - 2 Points - Fits the theme, and it makes for a really good sig.
Ethiopia - 1 Point - I like the effects and the sig overall.
Burningsun01
3 points- Celtic- Actually has some concept to it, rather than just saying *insert word here* is my paradise. Plus it's actually the most appealing. tongue.gif
2 points- Sheperd- Awwh. Tigers. :] Haha again, actually fits into the theme and the concept is nice. Tiger could have been messed with a little more so it wouldn't look quite so out of place, but it looks great nonetheless.
1 point- Dhru- Again, one of the few that actually followed the theme. The text isn't great though, and it could do with something more to give it appeal.
Celtic
3 points - Dhru, fantasy 'n shizzle, if I have to make up a stupid generic "cc" to for some arbitary reason legitimise my 3 points then "nice colours"

2 points - Runez, sharpness makes my eyes bleed BUT I LIKE JUXTAPOSITION SO 2 POINTS SIR

1 point - Ethiopia, not sure how much has actually been done BUT TEXT IS COOL SO 1 POINT!!!
Ptolemy
3 points Dwarrior - It doesn't really fit the theme, but I like the smudging, brushing, and the colors.

2 points Celtic - It matches the theme a lot, and I really like how you highlighted the "paradise" with the text.

1 point Arch - I love the colors, the brushing, and the text is awesome.



Lol at Poke. You just added a photo filter and managed the make the whole thing look awesome! smile.gif

tongue.gif
dabmasta
3 points- Ehtiopia: love everything about it

2 points- Sheperd: Really nice, but tiger is a bit blurry and overwhelmed


Nobody gets 1 point.

Good job to all
sanji
3pts celtic - cool concept, very movie-poster like but i feel u could use better colors
2pts runez - text is alright but tone down the sharpen
1pt dhru - looks cool and all but kinda monotone and text doesnt work
Swagga
celtic - really love how you put the text, fits in with the theme too.
nadson - don't really know how this goes with paradise, but oh well the colors match and i like the lighting.
arch - well i really don't like the colors but the text is alright.
Poke
Celtic, 3 pts: Actually fits with the theme and the text works well. The lens flare works really well.
Ethiopia, 2 pts: The wave blends well with everything else.
Kwinten, 1 pt: I actually liked the original without the lens flare, but there's some good filters in there and the reflecting text looks nice.

QUOTE (Ptolemy @ Jun 30 2009, 12:30 AM) *
Lol at Poke. You just added a photo filter and managed the make the whole thing look awesome! smile.gif

tongue.gif


I added every adjusment layer there was. ohmy.gif
Except for a few. Curves was one. I never understood that. pfft.gif
Kemosabe
Poke - I like the stock and the colours. It also fits the theme extremely well. 3 Points.
Kwinten- Looks very good. I like the text and the stock. 2 Points.
-Arch
Ahmad, 3 - Fits the theme and has nice color blending.
Trevor, 2 - Love the blending.
Mario, 1 - I like how you blended but text needs work.
Day
3- Celtic
You really got me with the text and the background... nice work!
2- Dwarrior
Smudging is great, render is clear... didn't exactly follow the theme tongue.gif
1- Dhru
Nice to the eyes, but just... didn't like the dragon outline thingy.
Fruityfed
Swagga, 3 - It's the only one that, to me, really felt like paradise. It stood out to me. I think maybe it's the color scheme.
Dhru, 2 - Really love the colors and that it went for more of a fantasy theme.
Celtic, 1 - I like the text and that it put a bit of a different spin on the theme by having two people.

I normally don't do much in this section, but ya know. tongue.gif
Thunderclaw
Shouldn't voting have been closed by now?
It's been a week since the voting topic was started.
Day
QUOTE (Thunderclaw @ Jul 6 2009, 04:20 PM) *
Shouldn't voting have been closed by now?
It's been a week since the voting topic was started.

Alright, I'll count up the votes.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.