Simple and I didn't do an in-game fake because that'd be a lot harder Don't be too harsh

Nice!.....10/10......Gode Job Mate....


~ Why Bother

The icons aren't really that bad, good job semi believable.

On first glance it looks perfect and you don't even notice that they aren't real skills!

I'll give it an 8/10, because the icons are a little bit odd, and it's not an ingame fake. Maybe follow it up with a stats screen fake?

Is that an html edit for the names of the skills? They are utterly flawless.

~Ork.

HTML edit, part of the necromancy looks wierd, the skills altogether don't add up to 300,000,000 xp, but it's good besides for allthat. 6.5/10

They could be real.. In fact, they should be in the game. Especially swimming!

9/10 - The icons are almost perfect.

Right, did you do the calculations on a calculator?...
On top of that I did not html edit, it's called using your brain and copying and pasting.
I don't see how necromancy looks weird, explain.

What's with the forum newbs? Tips for you new guys, here, we don't first glance rate and we check all flaws. Barely should it be 9 or 10.

-HTML edit. -2
-Not ingame -.5
-Wrong calculations -1
+Good icons +1
________________________________
7.5/10 Not bad...

9/10.
Doesn't add up to 300M

Yeah I did take the time to do it on a calculator, lol. (But I was using estimation, of course.)
And for the necromancy, I just don't see what it's supposed to be.

Execution is okay, the content isn't sadly. Necromancy would be a extension of Summoning if it was ever released, which I doubt, as it is basically the same as Summoning.
Swimming and Sailing would almost certainly be put in one common skill like Sea-Travel or Travel in general.

It may be good editing practice, but the idea is just as important in a fake.

I'm sorry for bumping this up again. I just took the time to do the calculations again, it added up to 300m still. For all you who said it didn't, make sure you got EVERY number correct...

And I see what you mean, Mario. Thanks everyone for commenting

Nice, those skills would be pretty cool to train

10/10, might wanna come up with ideas for the skills and take this to suggestions eh?

swimming might be like agility underwater

9/10, It looks nice but a little simple. Nice fake!

cool, looks authentic 10/10

Very nice 9.9/10. Believable, very good icons, simple, yet brilliant work.I actually added up the total exp + total level to see if you did your homework. You did. Great Job

9/10. Very good but you do know that Necromancy is/was the old Prayer. So you have 2 of the same skills.
~~Been playing since 2001.

Tbh i dont really consider this a fake its pretty easy to do.

7.5/10

It was the old magic skill.
Actually, I think Necromancer was one of the 'classes' you choose upon starting the game. It gave a higher level in Magic, which was then split into Good Magic and Evil Magic.

-2 html edits are very easy
-1 alphabetical order????
-1 necromancy icon looks wonky

6/10 not bad.

9/10. Nice icons

I actually think he is right about the Prayer thing, as I think it was Evil or Good Prayer, but I wasn't around back then...

He is right that there were two Prayers and Magics, but Necromancy was a class giving a boost in Magic(s) (it was later renamed to the Wizard class). Here's a shot of RS Classic's beta skill list (note the two Prayers, two Magics, Tailoring (later became part of crafting), and Influence (before quest points existed, you had an "influence" level that got raised by questing )):

I wasn't around back then either, but there's many things you can learn from RuneWiki

Why the heck would they take that out That's so awesome imo...

Pretty cool fake. 9/10.

I think the differences between classes was only by a few levels, such as +4 Magic levels. Also, other stats, like HP, were often lowered for non-combat classes (so it is possible for you to have level 8 HP ). You also got different starting items in each class, such as a pickaxe for miners and a Black Wizard Hat and Staff for Wizards/Necromancers. But regardless of what stat you picked, you still gain experience at the same rate, so you can easily chose the Wizard class and not train magic at all, and get your melee stats to high levels instead. So, basically, aside from a headstart in one or two skills, the system didn't do much. And remember, this was long before the game even had a tutorial - so all the items you get when you start the game are exclusively based on your class. After they scrapped the class system, players got the default item bonuses of the well-rounded Adventurer class. That lasted about 8 months, and then we got Tutorial Island. So I'm guessing the main reason they removed classes is because they had little impact on the players (think about how easy your first 5 levels in any skill were ), and the items you got could easily have been either bought from a general store, dropped from weak monsters, or found at an automatic spawn location (such as pickaxes at Lumbridge Castle).

sailing lol looks very good 9\10