Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Sotw 79 Voting
Sal's RuneScape Forum > Everything... Not RuneScape > The Graphics Place > Digital Gallery > Competitions & Projects
Kwinten
Theme: Out of the box

All voting rules apply. Please state good reasons why you vote for a person's siggy (you like the colors, lighting, the concept, etc). Please also clearly states who gets the most points (3 points for the best, 2 for second place, 1 point for third place).

Also, YOU MUST VOTE IF YOU ENTERED, or you will be disqualified.

Votings end the 9th of August.

Entries:

Spoiler: Click to Toggle the Spoiler.
Celtic


Fruityfed


Kwinten


Callahan90


Runez


Alann


Entrility


[Close]


Vote away!
Celtic
Well this is a dilemma, Runez + Alann have the only decent looking sigs but as far as I'm concerned have nothing to do with the theme so I'm dqing them in my mind. Callahan90's is also not on theme so I'm left with 3 to order.

3 pts - Kwinten, fits thematically best.

2 pts - Entrility, not really a fan but it is different I guess, looks ok on a black skin.

1pt - Fruity, obvious joke but its all I had left to vote for.


Kwinten are you enforcing "you enter you vote" because otherwise I garuntee this will probably be the only vote.
Kwinten
QUOTE (Celtic @ Aug 6 2009, 07:01 PM) *
Well this is a dilemma, Runez + Alann have the only decent looking sigs but as far as I'm concerned have nothing to do with the theme so I'm dqing them in my mind. Callahan90's is also not on theme so I'm left with 3 to order.

3 pts - Kwinten, fits thematically best.

2 pts - Entrility, not really a fan but it is different I guess, looks ok on a black skin.

1pt - Fruity, obvious joke but its all I had left to vote for.


Kwinten are you enforcing "you enter you vote" because otherwise I garuntee this will probably be the only vote.

Alright then, I'll enforce that.

I'm kind of having the same problem for voting too. Did I make the theme too hard? D:
My votes:

3pts - Celtic: Looks very neat, and handled the theme well.

2pts - Entrility: Looks good on black skin, and I guess it's kind of 'out of the box'.

1pt - Runez: Only because I love the colors so much. Although I don't see much relevance to the theme.
Fruityfed
3 points - Celtic. At first I thought it was just a bunch of random stuff but now I realize it's a box with a bunch of letters/words outside of it, which I like. biggrin.gif

2 points - Kwinten. The picture and the text match really nicely.

1 point - Entrility. Nice and abstract, but I don't really like the far right part.
Celtic
Just realised I saved mine as a low quality jpeg lol, oh well.
Wooden Gravy
3 Points - Runez - I just can't take my eyes off it, it's just, addictive. The colours, and everything, oooooohhhhh. I'm surprised at how it has no votes. slanty.gif
2 Points - Celtic - Just looks, 'right'. The rotation seems appropriate and the signature as a whole seems flawless.
1 Point - Fruityfed - For 1 Point it was between Fruityfed and Kwinten, but Fruityfed's was simple and easy, so I chose his.

Yeah, mine does seem a bit, off topic, although it is a bit random, and couldn't really fall under any other categories, so it's kind of out of the box...

Mhm.

Callahan90.

Entrility
1st - Fruityfed: I lol'd pretty hard. The simplicity is probably the best part about it.
2nd - Alann: Nice, soft colors, reminded me of watercolors from way back when :3
3rd - Runez: I'm not too sure how this fits the theme, but the coloration is amazing.
Kam
3pts -Celtic best overall
2pts -fruity it's funny and I basically flippe a coin between you and kwinten cause the others are really just freestyle sigs..
1pt -kwinten don't like it much but it's simple and nice
Runez
omg liek my canvas iz a box and colurz r coming out of it lulz!!11!!1

Just Kidding, I actually thought the theme was "thinking outside the box." A hot air balloon crashing into a rainbow was kinda like thinking outside of the box to me. cool.gif

Since I have to vote:
3pts Celtic - only one that looks like more than a 15 minute job + fits the theme
2pts Callahan - looks cool to me. i don't know. i like shiny things and turtles.
1pt - Kwinten - even though it looks like a 5 step job it still looks pretty good and fits the theme.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.