When I was lurker on these forums when of my favourite places to look at was here, I was amazed and amused by the fakes produced in here, and finally I have decided to give it a shot myself!

It's not very good (imo) but I got a satisfactory result in the end.



Rate it with whatever system you want, I'm open to all feedback .

As

It may look a little sloppy, but concept-wise, it looks great!

The metallic effect on the handle is amazing.

The lines are sloppy and jagged, and head could use some more shading.

The shading is superb, i recommend making the lines straighter and giving more definition to the spikes, right now they look flat.

7/10 overall, but that will easily go up if you fix a couple tiny mistakes

Also, maybe later if you make it item-sized you can have it in an "in-game-fake" where the character is either holding it or has it in their inventory

I love the effect, just like poke said. Nice job!

The outline looks horrible, and you should make it fit in your inventory. But the fact that you used a bunch of different colors is great. 6/10

It's okay concept art--the outline sorta looks weird, but the metallic effect is nice. As already stated, if you made an item-sized version, it would make a pretty good fake.

I'm trying very hard to ignore the black points, but other than that, it looks quite good if you trim it and fix it up a bit

I'd say 8/10.

A hammer with horns, wtf? I don't like were the horns are placed nor the way they look. And I'm guessing you didn't do the pixeling in paint.

No, don't think he did.
The handle looks like something made with the smudge tool.

Not bad.

Nice, A little sloppy but it's pretty amazing over all ( better than what I can do ) Over all I give it a 7/10!

Like Chaoss said, it'd be nicer if you made it item-sized, but I really like it
9/10

Just smooth out the outlines a bit, and you've got a nice fake!

the handle is amazing