i thought before you posted an idea that contained a do not suggest thing you were supposed to pm a mod and ask them if it was ok.

[08] Any suggestion dealing with any type of gun or firearm.

[07] Modern or futuristic items. (ion cannons in RuneScape?)

...and was made more modern with the word musket

The dwarf Musket is constructed of rune, and is blue in color, as all rune. The gun is rather large in size (about the size of a Two-Handed Sword), and is a yew-color in the stock. Although slower then most weapons in RuneScape, the Dwarf Rifle packs an incredible punch at a fair range. It operates on Metal Bullets only (Quests may be added, of new ammunition and muskets). The character will hold it with both hands, stock at shoulder, and fire. They will then rest it on the ground, pull back the slide, releasing the cartridge, and will put in a new cartridge. They will then hoist it back up and fire again. The Dwarf musket may only be constructed once, from the quest. But Skeleton Dwarf's will drop them as a rare drop. They will sell to a general store for 74K, low alchemy for 37.4K, and high alchemy for 128K. metal bullets will be made with the Smithing skill, and require a level of 70, and a steel bar will give off 5 bullets. Bullets will sell to a general store for 100 coins, low alchemy for 57, and high alchemy for 213.

Is there any chance that someone could organize the first post so that it includes the ideas posted in a spoiler?

Despite the Elaboration Rule being there, in a normal situation (without consulting a staff member), I believe that the Forbidden Items would overrule said rule.



Note the emphasis on 'any'. Guns/Firearms are far beyond the setting of RuneScape (which would be medieval of course).

Also note the seventh rule:



And concerning error404:



The thing is, items like these are not supposed to be modernized or made more modern.

You're suggestion's explanation is as below:



See the bold words: Gun, Rifle, Bullets, Ammunition. These words make the suggestion very much modern, and I doubt that Dwarves could use such a thing.



It would certainly make the thread easier to search. Perhaps the list would index all the items or skills with what page number they're on next to it...

Sorry ment to say less modern lol and I mean the bold words you highlighed, can't they be reworded? Although it is under the do not suggest rules, I think the do not suggest rules are very harsh, so harsh that I see not many suggestions being posted

I'd rather less suggestions being posted then being flooded with moronic suggestions on a daily basis like it was.

Moronic suggestions get locked obviously but I think the no suggest rules need to be more flexible.

Its been said thousands of time before, I made a suggestion for old age pistols as a mage weapon where runes are crushed to create different powders. Was a very elaborated suggestion and was stil lshut. Surely if a topic follows the other suggestion rules this one is unneeded?

The big point for me is that there should be something in the rules about contacting a mod if you want an exception to a rule. As is there is nothing in there saying that as far as I know, yet I've gotten around rules before just by clearing it first and making it a good suggestion.