So this is my first fake. I could see some flaws but it's pretty basic so please don't rate it on how basic it is. I just want to see how realistic it looks.

Warning large image!!



Also the duck looks cut off . Also the scroll looks messed up where I erased the original words.

There isn't any flaws as far as I can see, but it's very simple, so I'd have to rate it 6/10.

Well done, though.

Not bad, a very good first fake.

You missed out the part where it says something along the lines 'Congratulations! You are now a master of Strength! Why not visit Sloane at the Warrior's Guild? He has something special that is only avaliable to true masters of the Strength skill!'

Another flaw: You already have 138 cmb if you had 98 strength and all other combat skills on 99

He had his private on public.

for what I think it looks bad . I took this on my noob acc when it got 10 strength.

It shows up on the congrats scroll.