Hello, i'm new to these forums so this is also my Welcome thread xD
a little bit about me: I'm a Photoshopper i make alot of interface's for private servers, Custom made game's ( I guess im too noob for official games )
i also love to fool around photoshopping Excisting world area's or just simply make a little Tag wall/Wallpaper/Series of sigs or Lp's.
I use Adobe Photoshop Cs4 Extended, and Adobe Illustrator Cs4 pro.
i normally just use renders from games or manga series, but when i really feel like being creative i just open up illustrator and make my own renders.

now back to the topic and here's my fake!
-- I couldn't get the Text right imo:( --

-1 Shadow of options in left top corner is off
-1 Background Blurry, while zombie is crisp
-1 Old Minimap
-1 Gun not RuneScapeish
+1 first fake
+1 Great idea

8/10 Great fake, very good.

lol i love it, but minimap is a bit blury

I hope you mean non-Runescape private servers.
Because using a private server is against the rules here, and if you use them in your fakes you'll be killed in your sleep by Poke.

I'm not really picky about the time of day. I am picky about fakes though.
-2 Old interface over the top. You had the options and the resources to use an updated one, but you completely ignored them. What surprises me is the rest is up to date.
-3 Text is seriously messed up. The shadow should always be 1px down 1px right. Yours are just all over the place.
-2 Minimap. It's old and has been blown up way out of proportion.
-1 The alignment of the colon after the QC button is wrong.
-1 The circles and the square in the minimap have no shadows behind them.
-1 The gun in the inventory looks nothing at all like a real RS item.
-1 There's something wrong with the Prayer button by the minimap.
-1 There's something wrong with above the minimap too.
-1 And the compass.
-1 And the X symbol in the top-right corner.

Starting at 10, you end up with -4.


-1 The 'Nooo' in the chatbox is the wrong colour.

*ahem*
Lets see here...

-1 old minimap
-1 wrong colour for wha the zombie say in the chatbox
-1 lack of shadow
-1 inventory looks a little...
-1 Old tool bar at the top
-1 "x" is out of place
-/+ you used a private server to make this
+1 great idea
+1 first fake
+1 gun and hand is well done

7/10

Not bad.

Starting at 10 is fairly biased.

2/10, using what he rated above.