well hey there,
i present to you my new fakes
my main fake great fire of lumbridge and my side fake jagex decides to put a bucket of water`s price in the grand exchange up a bit just at the wrong time

the main fake:


and the side fake:


i hope you like these fakes!

Noxas mage22 -

Ok, your second one was all right. The first was terrible- not even a full screen fake! (Chatbox, map, etc).

First one

-2 Fire is unrunescapish
-1 Simplicity
-1 Not even a full screen fake.
+1 You tried.

1/5 stars.
*****

Second one

I can't rate the second- barely a fake.

Um the fire could have been more real but otherwise
its a really nice fake!
5/10

I'll give you a 6/10 for the IDEA, but the fake itself deserves a 3/10. It's a basic crop+paste fake, only one crop and only one paste.

Why the hell would you need a map for?

I think it's fine without an interface.

It's a basic necessity of a fake to show all of the parts including chat box mini map etc.

...not necessarily. Even if you did add a chatbox, minimap, inventory, and all the goods, if the stuff is going to be mostly blank and unnecessary, adding the stuff may not be needed. However, I do believe that a chatbox and stuff would add considerably to the fakes.

The first fake could really exist, excepting the extremely pixelly, unrealistic flames which don't fit into the screenie whatsoever. The second is virtually flawless, but is very simple to make.

4/10 overall.

[/quote]
Why the hell would you need a map for?

It's a basic necessity of a fake to show all of the parts including chat box mini map etc.
[/quote]
...not necessarily. Even if you did add a chatbox, minimap, inventory, and all the goods, if the stuff is going to be mostly blank and unnecessary, adding the stuff may not be needed. However, I do believe that a chatbox and stuff would add considerably to the fakes.

The first fake could really exist, excepting the extremely pixelly, unrealistic flames which don't fit into the screenie whatsoever. The second is virtually flawless, but is very simple to make.

4/10 overall.
[/quote]

thank you i never really put in the map and such because it gets irratating cause i have to make it messy and paint over the names of my friends and stuff
sorry about pixelated flame i wanted it bigger
but im glad someone noticed how good second fake is

Grrr... you messed up the quotes...
Well actually there's a very simple solution for that, just your private chat off.
The first one isn't very good, but the second one is probably the best fake I've seen you make yet.

lols. im guessing you made the fire by taking a pic of a ordinary log-fire, took the logs away, and magnified it. thats why the fire seem so blurry.

-2 Bad Fire
-2 The fire isnt very big
-0.5 Showed only part of the whole picture
-1 Simple Cut-And-Paste
___________________________________
+1 Nice Try
+0.5 Pretty Neat Work
+0.5 The side fake's pretty OK
+0.5 An NPC is facing the same direction, seems to add towards the realistic-tivity(such word??)

Total: 7/10
Nice Try

Second one was much more funnier.
Not really much faking just changing txt.
The first one was terrible quality, and the fire didn't look realistic.

That's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard.
I made interface fakes. I only made the interface, not all the background stuff like Minimap and Chatbox. Do you think I could've gotten better ratings if I had that stuff?


As for the Fake:
Fake 1:
-3 Simple Copy, zoom, and paste of a fire.
-1 Not that Great of a fire, is it? When I clicked on the thread I was expecting buildings to be burning, not for someone to have lit a campfire atop of the general store.
6/10

Fake 2:
It's not fake, blame the merchanting clans.
You executed the fake well, and there are no flaws, but I could compare that to pushing a button correctly. It's an utterly simple fake, and I can't give more than a 7/10 for it.

Main Fake:
-2 Fire Graphics (No shading and no "glow")
-1 Where the Great Fire???
7/10
Secondary Fake:
Nothing wrong except for very simple idea. 10/10