Jump to content
Sal's RuneScape Forum
  • entries
    346
  • comments
    1,140
  • views
    242,592

Superheroes and the Lone Ranger

Helm Lardar

807 views

I like superheroes in fiction. That might not seem controversial, but for some reason plenty of superhero films are derided, apparently for containing them. Problem with those films is that quite often they don't call the leads superheroes, even when they are. The audience is expected to infer it.

 

 

That means half the time the audience doesn't. Then they start complaining about how the story doesn't make sense, or how it's too cheesy, or how important things aren't explained, or how a particular character is absurd, etc etc. Some of these criticisms turn out to be legitimate, but some don't.

 

Let's name four superheroes. Sherlock Holmes. Spiderman. The Lone Ranger. Tonto.

 

Only one of these are announced: Spiderman, who decides the best way to use his powers is to make a special suit and gadgets, and fight crime as a masked man with a fancy name. But they've all got superpowers in their latest iterations: Sherlock can make inhuman deductions and clues visibly manifest themselves as text to his eyes, Spiderman has outrageous reflexes, superb strength, and the knowledge to make previously unheard of spider-related kit, the Lone Ranger is immortal (in battle) and can't miss, and Tonto is a skinwalker who can communicate with animals and otherwise find protection.

 

Now they're all fun to watch, as long as you recognise that they're in a trope. They're not meant to be taken seriously. But many people somehow think they are, and expect something of them that they can't deliver. Stories like that of The Lone Ranger, in the latest film of that name, should be taken as enjoyable stories, but not held to the standards of something intended to be analysed as a rational tale.

 

Which is why I was shocked (shocked!) to see The Lone Ranger lambasted so. It's a fun superhero film. If we can enjoy Spiderman or Sherlock, why can't we enjoy this?



3 Comments


Recommended Comments

I disagree, neither the Lone Ranger or Tonto is a superhero. Sherlock Holmes is definitely not. They just are very good at what they do, not superhuman. The things they do should be in the realm of possibilities/physics-legal. I haven't seen any of those movies so I can't comment.

Share this comment


Link to comment

I am referring specifically to the latest iterations, ie the TV show 'Sherlock' and the 2013 film 'The Lone Ranger'.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Guidelines and Privacy Policy.