If this "bunch" of mathematicians and scientists knows so much, why haven't the other thousands of mathemeticians and scientists agreed with them? Rather than insulting his intelligience, why don't you explain the logic behind the equation, or at least space it out a little so its easier to understand, because it doesn't seem to make any sense to me. The experiemt he's talking about is called the Miller-Urey experiment, and in it, inorganic substances basically created organic ones. Since it took an unimaginably short time compared to the history of the universe, i don't find it at all hard to believe that over a few billion years, these organic materials could evolve into cells.
Isn't it obvious? Wasn't that experiment conducted by humans, as actual intelligent beings? Whereas life on Earth, taking the athiest train of thought, was made by no intelligence at all. It just coincidentally formed cells.
Also, if the thousands of mathematicians who were not involved in the decision did not agree with them (which you haven't given any evidence for this being widely known), then would not they disprove it? Can you disprove that 382nd power calculation?
I don't think Emanick was trying to insult anyone's intelligence. I think he was just trying to say that Evin agreed with him on this, and that hopefully he would come on and say so soon.