Best Ice Cream Flavor

[Guitarguy]

There is one correct answer, of course.

Edited May 8, 2017 by Guitarguy

[Sobend]

Cookies and Cream is pretty good. But my personal favorite is death by chocolate.

[Leo]

[Shooter585]

Nothing against cookies and cream but I don't think it is deserving of this distinction. Idk which is my favorite but imo these are better

• death by chocolate
  
• chocolate chip cookie dough
  
• Strawberry (oldie but a goodie)
  
• Moose tracks!!!
  

[Fatalysm]

Clotted cream ice cream

 

The majority of you have never tried this and cannot refute my claims. :P

[Kemosabe]

Cookies and Cream is good, but Hokey Pokey is hands down the best flavour of ice cream.

[Chaoss]

Cookies and cream is quite good but it's gotta be cookie overload. I find too many overly vanilla versions so I gotta disagree with the poll.

 

The real answer is moose tracks. You can't ask for something better than that. Salted Caramel is a recent contender though. And of course you can't go wrong with mint.

[Fatalysm]

Cookies and Cream is good, but Hokey Pokey is hands down the best flavour of ice cream.

That doesn't even sound real!

 

Knickerbocker glory however....that...that is real.

 

Edit: Hokey pokey is just honeycomb..!

Edited May 17, 2017 by Fatalysm

[Lonelywolf]

Ben and jerrys new chunky mum butt 3000 is my favourite

[KaBob]

Dreyer's/Edy's had this amazing butterfinger ice cream a while back. Other than that, plain old strawberry (especially blue bells) and cookies and cream are both great. If I could invent my own flavor though, butterfinger and oreo go together amazing in ice cream.

Edited June 14, 2017 by KaBob

[Phoenix Rider]

Vanilla. Anything else is wrong.

[Fatalysm]

Vanilla. Anything else is wrong.

If at some point in your life you find a french vanilla anything but most importantly a french vanilla ice cream, you must obtain this and blow your mind on the richer deeper taste. I would say it tastes a lot like custard but i'm not sure if you've ever had custard.

[Phoenix Rider]

Vanilla. Anything else is wrong.

If at some point in your life you find a french vanilla anything but most importantly a french vanilla ice cream, you must obtain this and blow your mind on the richer deeper taste. I would say it tastes a lot like custard but i'm not sure if you've ever had custard.

 

Oh, I know what you mean. There's vanilla then there's French vanilla.

[William Howard Taft]

Peanut butter and chocolate, no exceptions.

[fastpacer]

Cookies and cream and Vanilla.

[Buland]

Chocolate's the king of flavours. Vanilla's just a base-flavour so I hardly consider it a separate flavour.